Friday, August 12, 2005

8/11: "There's no rebuilding, no weapons, nothing," said retired Iraqi Lt. Gen. Abdul Aziz al-Yaseri, who worked in the Defense Ministry.

Audit: Fraud drained $1 billion from Iraq's defense efforts

By Hannah Allam,
Knight Ridder Newspapers
Thu Aug 11, 6:04 PM ET

BAGHDAD, Iraq - Iraqi investigators have uncovered widespread fraud and waste in more than $1 billion worth of weapons deals arranged by middlemen who reneged or took huge kickbacks on contracts to arm Iraq's fledgling military, according to a confidential report and interviews with U.S. and Iraqi officials.

The Iraqi Board of Supreme Audit, in a report reviewed by Knight Ridder, describes transactions suggesting that senior U.S.-appointed Iraqi officials in the Defense Ministry used three intermediary companies to hide the kickbacks they received from contracts involving unnecessary, overpriced or outdated equipment.

Knight Ridder reported last month that $300 million in defense funds had been lost. But the report indicates that the audit board uncovered a much larger scandal, with losses likely to exceed $500 million, that's roiling the ministry as it struggles to build up its armed forces.

The episode deprives Iraq's military of essential gear that could help prepare the way for U.S. forces to withdraw. It also raises questions about the new government's ability to provide an effective defense against an entrenched insurgency and win broad acceptance among Iraqis.

The audit board's investigators looked at 89 contracts of the past year and discovered a pattern of deception and sloppiness that squandered more than half the Defense Ministry's annual budget aimed at standing up a self-sufficient force, according to a copy of the 33-page report.

Its revelations offer the most comprehensive look to date at corruption that allegedly thrived for eight months or longer even with about 20 American civilian advisers working alongside Iraqi defense chiefs, including those now under investigation. The report does not suggest that U.S. advisers were involved in any corruption.

"If one dinar is misspent, I ache for it, so just imagine how it feels for such huge sums," Iraqi Prime Minister Ibrahim al-Jaafari said in an interview Wednesday. "We need it to build the country and, even if we reach the level to where we don't need it, we aren't about to give our money over to corruption."

The U.S. Embassy in Baghdad, which oversees civilian advisers to the Iraqi Ministry of Defense, didn't consent to on-the-record interviews about the investigation. In response to a request for comment, it issued a statement that said embassy officials were aware of the allegations and that, even before they became public, "we were advising the Iraqis about our concerns relating to MoD decisions on procurement and the possibility of corruption."

Iraqi Defense Minister Saadoun al-Dulaimi confirmed most of audit board report's findings in an interview last Sunday, saying that at least $500 million in Iraqi money essentially has disappeared. He's removed nine senior officials so far - he fired the ministry's procurement chief and placed his own deputy minister, Bruska Shaways, on leave - and said he was working through a list of other employees who faced dismissal and possible criminal charges.

"This is not only the Defense Ministry's problem. It affects the image of the new Iraq," al-Dulaimi said. "If we really spent that money in the right way, maybe it would have given us more capabilities to face terrorists."

The Board of Supreme Audit, led by former Human Rights Minister Abdel Baset al-Turki, examined defense contracts that had been signed starting with the transfer of sovereignty June 28, 2004, through Feb. 28, 2005. The investigation's results, supported by bank statements, receipts and internal Defense Ministry memos, were delivered to al-Jaafari's office May 16.

Among the findings:

-Multimillion-dollar contracts were awarded to favored weapons suppliers without a bidding process and without the required approval from the prime minister's office. Investigators wrote that the chief procurer went "beyond his authority" in purchasing equipment.

-Senior Iraqi officials kept little or no record of major purchases, sometimes noting lucrative deals in "undated and unnumbered" memos. Nearly all purchases contained a clause - unusual in international contracting of this magnitude - that required the contract's full value to be paid up front in cash.

-Instead of buying directly from a foreign company or government, Iraqi arms procurers hired third-party companies to negotiate the contracts. When Iraqi leaders later complained about unfulfilled contracts, they discovered they had no recourse to demand a refund because the payments were made to Iraqi middlemen who vanished after receiving the millions. "The undertakings make no obligation ... toward the Iraqi Ministry of Defense," according to the report.

-The sole beneficiary on 43 of the 89 contracts was a former currency-exchange operator, Nair Mohamed al-Jumaili, whose name doesn't even appear on the contracts. At least $759 million in Iraqi money was deposited into his personal account at a bank in Baghdad, according to the report. Internal records incorrectly "indicated that the Ministry of Defense signed contracts with Poland, Arab countries, the United States and Europe, but we discovered that all contracts were signed and executed with Iraqi suppliers," the report said.

The contracts under scrutiny total $1.27 billion, nearly equal to the estimated $1.3 billion allocated for the Defense Ministry's budget this year. The money came solely from Iraqi coffers, not from the training budget of the U.S. military or from NATO and foreign donations to Iraq's military.

"There's no rebuilding, no weapons, nothing," said retired Iraqi Lt. Gen. Abdul Aziz al-Yaseri, who worked in the Defense Ministry at the height of the alleged corruption. "There are no real contracts, even. They just signed papers and took the money."

Lt. Gen. David H. Petraeus, who oversees the U.S. military's training of Iraqi troops, conducts weekly briefings with the defense minister. Other Iraqi defense officials seldom are spotted without American civilian advisers nearby. The close relationship has raised questions as to how $500 million or more could vanish without U.S. intervention to stop the suspicious contracts that flowed for at least eight months.

"Ask them. I have the same question," al-Dulaimi said. "I blame those who posted them (the officials under investigation). And, by the way, the CPA posted them."

He was referring to the Coalition Provisional Authority, the occupation-era administration that American Ambassador L. Paul Bremer oversaw. Al-Dulaimi, other Iraqi politicians and some U.S. military officials blamed the CPA for forcing the Defense Ministry to hire previously unknown Iraqi officials, especially former exiles, without consulting Iraqi leaders.

Petraeus' spokesmen and U.S. Embassy officials said they raised concerns about corruption rumors but were constrained from doing more to prevent the alleged wrongdoing because a sovereign Iraqi government was in place. However, Iraqi politicians, eager to deflect blame ahead of the coming election season, said Americans introduced a culture that allowed room for corruption and that the Americans could have done more to protect the Iraqi public's money.

"Before me, there was another prime minister. His name was Bremer," Ayad Allawi, who served as interim premier when the corruption investigation began sometime last year, told Knight Ridder. "He ran this country, he had this ministry and a lot of the corruption started then. ... There was no auditing. Airplanes were flying in and the money was handed out in suitcases."

Former Defense Minister Hazem Shaalan has told U.S. and Iraqi officials that Bremer personally requested that Ziad Cattan - the alleged ringleader of the corruption and the ministry's former procurement chief - stay in his job after sovereignty was transferred last summer.

Bremer said this week, through his former CPA spokesman Dan Senor, that he didn't know Cattan. "At least to his knowledge, he'd never met him," Senor said.

Cattan, a dual Polish-Iraqi national, was fired in May and a warrant was issued for his arrest in connection with "the abuse of an employer's funds." He fled Baghdad and hasn't returned to answer the charges.

Col. John Martin, Petraeus' deputy for political-military affairs, said the general as well as high-ranking American and British defense advisers warned Allawi's defense chiefs of "their concerns about the lack of transparency in MoD procurement, the uncoordinated manner in which MoD procurement was proceeding and the possibility for - and rumors of - corruption."

"They also repeatedly warned the MOD that Dr. Ziad Cattan, in addition to procuring items Iraq did need, was also reportedly purchasing items the country did not need and could not afford to purchase, operate or sustain," Martin said. "At the end of the day, however, this was Iraqi money being spent by Iraqi officials of a sovereign country's ministry."

Even as hints of a corruption scandal emerged last spring, Cattan told others in the ministry that U.S. Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld personally had assured his job and no Iraqi had the power to remove him, al Dulaimi said. Instead of fleeing the investigation closing in on him, Cattan lobbied for even more authority. He wanted to become defense minister, a seat reserved for a Sunni Arab by al Jaafari's Shiite-dominated government, which was elected last January.

Cattan, a Sunni, contacted the Iraqi National Dialogue Committee, the main Sunni faction negotiating with al-Jaafari on Cabinet appointments, and offered members $10 million cash to nominate him as their candidate for the post, said Mohammed al-Daini and two other committee members who heard Cattan's proposal. The group refused, and al-Jaafari handed the post to al-Dulaimi, a British-educated sociologist who isn't implicated in the scandal.

In several e-mail messages last month, Cattan gave Knight Ridder photos and documents purporting to show his close working relationship with U.S. officials and his repeated requests for their help in streamlining the contracting process. He denied wrongdoing, but acknowledged that some Western officials who are accustomed to peacetime standards might take exception to the aggressive weapons procurement he conducted to quickly arm an Iraqi force against the insurgency.

"We support this when conditions are quiet and normal, but we cannot disregard or overlook the bloody actuality and stick to the ... procedures imposed on us," Cattan wrote to his superiors in a memo dated May 29, around the time of his dismissal. "We cannot stay handcuffed."

When the extent of the alleged corruption leaked to the U.S. Embassy, senior diplomats were "hopping mad," said an official with the U.S.-led Iraq Reconstruction Management Office who has personal knowledge of the Defense Ministry's transactions. He spoke on condition of anonymity Wednesday because he could face dismissal for discussing the matter without authorization.

"The entire embassy was upside down over this," he said. "I swear to God the advisers didn't know everything going on over there. Where did they get their information? From the Iraqis. I can give you one budget that says this country is flourishing and another that tells you this country is going to s---. The Iraqis told us only what they wanted us to hear."

While many of the contracts did result in useful, if overpriced, equipment for Iraq's 80,000 new troops, contracts involving shoddily refurbished helicopters from Poland, crates of loose ammunition from Pakistan and a fleet of leak-prone armored personnel carriers were among purchases that now are deemed unnecessary or unusable.

With the money paid in advance and no mechanism for a refund, al-Dulaimi said, the Defense Ministry is negotiating with weapons dealers to substitute the equipment for more useful items such as guns, radio communications and other vital supplies.

"It's chaos," al-Dulaimi said, visibly exasperated. "It's a result of all the chaos brought to Iraq."




Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have been looking for sites like this for a long time. Thank you! 1991 infiniti wheel caps printer cartridges hp botox 100 free sprint ringtone International tennis championships 2006 Access provider internet service bonanza isp Of water sport club Microsoft access training new york ny Forex trading program Fl liposuction ultrasonic diamond engagement rings value city furniture how to repair hotpoint clothes dryer Legal forms photo Raising low blood pressure naturally patio heaters Bdsm stories of spanking machines Didrex on line01010101010101010101010101010101 threat management training taxi eyeglass frames eyewear

2:53 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

michael kors outlet online
versace sunglasses
ferragamo shoes
ray ban sunglasses
nike outlet
iphone case
coach outlet online
puma shoes
michael kors outlet
fitflops sale
ray ban sunglasses
hollister uk
cazal sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses sale
puma outlet
yeezy boost
fitflops sale
cheap uggs
longchamp solde
michael kors outlet
kobe shoes
adidas shoes
coach outlet
converse shoes
mulberry handbags
louis vuitton neverfull sale
rolex watches
polo pas cher
michael kors handbags clearance
christian louboutin outlet
montblanc pens
ugg uk
true religion outlet
michael kors uk
ugg outlet

4:36 AM  
Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

christian louboutin outlet
kansas city chiefs jerseys
rolex replica
nike roshe run
los angeles lakers
air jordan 4
san francisco 49ers jerseys
kate spade sale
polo ralph lauren
cheap ray bans

9:10 PM  
Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

cheap jordan shoes
ralph lauren uk
oakley sunglasses
ralph lauren outlet
chargers jerseys
steelers jerseys
mlb jerseys
christian louboutin shoes
coach outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet

3:33 AM  
Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

prada outlet
seattle seahawks jerseys
birkenstock outlet
bruberry sale
oakley sunglasses
nike outlet store
ray ban sunglasses
saints jerseys
abercrombie and fitch
asics shoes

9:01 PM  
Blogger qqqqqq said...

air max 2017
golden goose
birkin bag
nike air max
michael jordan shoes
van cleef arpels
longchamp bags
converse outlet
timberland boots

4:14 AM  
Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

green bay packers jerseys
coach outlet
los angeles lakers
nike air huarache
carolina panthers jersey
mbt shoes
nhl jerseys
basketball shoes
coach factory outlet
air jordan 8

8:49 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

the north face
nike outlet
beats by dre
moncler jackets
tommy hilfiger pas cher
longchamp bags
yeezy shoe
dansko outlet
ralph lauren uk

9:11 PM  
Anonymous Obat Gatal Kudis/Gudik said...

This information is very useful. thank you for sharing. and I will also share information about health through the website

Cara Menghilangkan Bopeng
Obat Penyakit Kulit Eksim
Obat Alami Tekanan Darah Tinggi/Hipertensi
Cara Mengobati Gusi Bengkak
Cara Menyembuhkan Mata Minus
perawatan kesehatan mata

3:33 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

nike outlet
nike air max 90
oakley sunglasses wholesale
coach outlet online
cheap jordan shoes
los angeles lakers
ray ban sunglasses
nike shoes
texans jerseys
true religion outlet

10:45 PM  
Blogger Raya Resmana said...

very interesting information, I really like it because it can add insight for me more broadly, thank you very much for this extraordinary information
4 gejala diabetes pada wanita yang harus diwaspadai

2:16 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...


nike store uk
michael kors handbags
giuseppe zanotti outlet
nhl jerseys
polo ralph lauren
canada goose
prada sunglasses
manolo blahnik outlet
canada goose jackets
fitflops sale clearance

4:31 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

ugg boots clearance
nike huarache
christian louboutin outlet
mlb jerseys
jordan shoes
fitflops sale
ray ban eyeglasses
christian louboutin shoes
coach factory outlet
mbt shoes outlet

11:47 PM  
Blogger 56 said...

0806jejeHalloween baskets nike roshe run print a un bon souvenir dans le cœur de soldes nike air revolution sky hi beaucoup d'entre nous qui se nike air max thea noir et blanche pas cher souvient du plaisir que nous avons asics gel lyte homme beige eu en tant que petits enfants asics gel lyte homme pas cher à se déguiser et à se nike air jordan sc 1 pas cher risquer à des événements sans ubiq x asics gel lyte v midnight bloom pas cher parler de «trucage ou traitement». Il nike air max 90 sneakerboot best price y a beaucoup d'autres marques aussi. adresse boutique nike france

9:42 PM  
Blogger Rairaka Herbal said...

teusalah memang maca informasi dina website ieu, raresep jeung araneh infona, nambah wawasan pisan
Cara Mengatasi Sakit Kepala Disertai Kliyengan Akibat Asam Lambung Naik

2:49 AM  
Blogger John said...

adidas neo shoes
juicy couture
coach bags
nike air force
coach outlet store
coach outlet store online
coach bags
coach outlet online
chaussures christian louboutin
converse shoes

9:08 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home